Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Carmody's avatar

Great article and many good points made - probably an anglophile thing but skills sets for Rugby and Cricket are the equal of if not far superior to NFL and baseball imho - so mystified as to the huge difference in ranking. Rugby - 80 mins of non stop action with each player having to demonstrate a wide range of skills -speed /dexterity/agility/decision making. Yes certainly there are specialist positions but all players need to be able to run/pass/kick/tackle - an if facing a small projectile from 22 yards travelling sometimes in excess of 150Km per hour - or catching the same projectile traveling a pace from half the distance of a short stop is a recreation I dont want to play games at your house. By the way - doesn't the silly hat thing also drop baseball to a simple recreational sport?

Expand full comment
Herbert Jacobi's avatar

It's said the hardest thing to do in sports is to hit a baseball. The ability to see the pitch, "know" if it's a strike or a ball and what kind of pitch has to be done in a split second. That implies attributes that can't be taught. Improved upon but not taught. So where does that particular skill fit in? And does that make Babe Ruth the greatest athlete of all time?

Expand full comment
73 more comments...

No posts